Best Sellers

Father's Day Gift Guide: Cheers to Dad with Sweet Treats & Savory Delights

Father's Day Gift Guide: Cheers to Dad with Sweet Treats & Savory Delights

This Father's Day, skip the tie and socks and give Dad a gift he'll truly savor. Treat him to the ultimate indulgence with our handcrafted pies and cakes, made with the finest ingredients and a whole lot of love. Whether he's a whiskey aficionado, a chocolate lover, or a fan of classic flavors, we've got something to satisfy every dad's sweet tooth. From boozy delights to dad-approved bestsellers, our Father's Day collection is sure to make his day extra special.


🥃 Boozy Delights for the Whiskey-Loving Dad:

  • Whiskey Pecan Pie: Indulge Dad's taste buds with our irresistible Whiskey Pecan Pie. A generous amount of premium pecans are nestled in a luscious filling infused with the warmth of fine whiskey. Each slice delivers a symphony of flavors, striking the perfect balance between sweet indulgence and a subtle whiskey kick, all crowned with a luxurious whiskey glaze.

       Slice of Whiskey Pecan Pie, garnished with pecans and creme, in front of an 11" pie from which it was cut and a glass of whiskey.

  • Irish Whiskey Cheesecake: Elevate Dad's dessert experience with this boozy twist on a classic! A rich and creamy cheesecake infused with just the right amount of Irish Whiskey sits atop a decadent chocolate graham cracker crust. Topped with a light and airy whipped cream, this dessert delivers a perfect balance of sweet, creamy, and spirited flavors that'll have Dad saying "Cheers!"

      Slice of Irish Whiskey Cheesecake, garnished with chocolate powder and a dollop of crème, in front of a 9" cake from which it was cut.

  • Tres Leches Cake: Delight Dad with this beloved Latin American dessert. Our light and airy sponge cake is soaked in a decadent blend of three milks creating a moist and flavorful experience. This classic treat is perfect for satisfying any sweet tooth and bringing a smile to Dad's face.

      Slice of Tres Leches Cake, garnished with blueberries, strawberries, blackberries, and crème, in front of a 9" cake from which it was cut.


🥧 Dad-Approved Best Sellers:

  • Dude Cake: Indulge Dad's inner child with this grown-up twist on an old time classic. Our decadent Dude Cake features layers of moist, golden butter cake generously filled and frosted with our signature, silky smooth chocolate buttercream. It's a chocolate lover's dream come true, perfect for celebrating the man who deserves a little extra sweetness in his life.

      A slice of Dude Cake, garnished with strawberries, in front of a 9" cake from which it was cut.

  • Coconut Supreme Pie: Treat Dad to a taste of the tropics with our Coconut Supreme Pie. This heavenly dessert is a symphony of textures and flavors, featuring a creamy, custardy coconut filling overflowing with shredded coconut and crowned with a generous layer of toasted coconut. All nestled within our signature flaky crust, it's a slice of paradise that's sure to transport Dad to his happy place.

      Slice of Coconut Supreme pie, garnished with a dollop of crème on top and toasted coconut flakes, in front of an 11" pie from which it was cut.

  • Lemon Icebox Pie: Treat Dad to a refreshing escape with our Lemon Icebox Pie. This tangy-sweet sensation features a cool, creamy lemon filling bursting with vibrant citrus flavor, all nestled in a buttery, handcrafted graham cracker crust. Light yet satisfying, it's the perfect summer indulgence for any occasion.

      slice of lemon pie

  • Tootie's Original Huge Apple Pie: Go big or go home this Father's Day with our legendary Huge Apple Pie! This colossal creation is overflowing with fresh, hand-peeled apples, perfectly spiced and nestled beneath a generous blanket of our famous, flaky crust. Weighing in at almost 6 pounds, it's a show-stopping centerpiece for any celebration and a guaranteed way to satisfy Dad's sweet tooth (and then some!).

      Slice of Huge Apple Pie in front of an 11" pie from which it was cut.


🎁 Gifts That Keep on GivingA Full Day of Deliciousness for Dad  🎁

Looking for ways to make Dad's Father's Day extra special? Go beyond a single pie or cake and treat him to a full day of deliciousness with our handpicked suggestions. From a hearty brunch to a satisfying dinner and a sweet finish, we've got you covered with options to celebrate Dad from morning till night. 

  • Boozy Pie Sampler: Can't decide which boozy pie Dad will love most? Treat him to the best of both worlds with our Whiskey Pecan and Irish Whiskey Cheesecake pies! Each pie is meticulously crafted with premium spirits and the finest ingredients, ensuring a truly unforgettable Father's Day indulgence. Order both for the ultimate tasting experience and let Dad savor the rich flavors of these handcrafted masterpieces.
  • Dad's Day Dinner: Make Father's Day a feast to remember with our savory Chicken Pot Pie and decadent Dude Cake bundle! Start with a comforting, hearty meal of tender chicken, vegetables, and creamy gravy encased in a flaky, golden crust. Then, satisfy Dad's sweet tooth with our rich, dark chocolate cake, layered with luscious chocolate ganache and drizzled with velvety chocolate fudge. It's the perfect combination of savory and sweet to celebrate the special man in your life.
  • Dad's All-Day Feast: Treat Dad to a culinary adventure from sunup to sundown with our handpicked trio of Tootie Pie favorites. Start his day with a savory Papas Rancheros Quiche for brunch, packed with zesty flavors and hearty ingredients. For dinner, delight him with our comforting Chicken Pot Pie, brimming with tender chicken and vegetables in a creamy sauce. And to top it all off, let him choose his favorite dessert pie for a sweet ending to a perfect day. It's a feast fit for a king, and the ultimate way to show Dad how much you care.

Don't forget to add a personalized message to your gift to make it extra special! We also offer in-store pickup, local delivery or nationwide shipping for your convenience.

This Father's Day, go beyond the ordinary and give Dad a gift he'll truly cherish. With our handcrafted pies, decadent cakes, and boozy delights, you're sure to find the perfect way to celebrate the special man in your life. Order now and make this Father's Day a delicious and unforgettable one!



Reading next

🍋 10 Surprising Uses for Lemons: Beyond Lemonade and Pies! 🍋
🍰 Picnic-Perfect Pie Pairings: Elevate Your Outdoor Feast 🍰

Leave a comment

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.