Behind the Pie: From Our Kitchen To Yours - July 2025

Why we think Nine is Fine - and why we raised our prices for the first time in four years

For the past few years, you’ve been telling us that our 11” pies make great gifts, but they’re too much pie for everyday eating. And we also hear that our 8” pies aren’t quite enough. So we’re betting that you’ll agree that nine is fine - 9”’ pies, that is. Don’t worry, you’ll still be able to get our famous Huge Apple Pie, and if you really, really, really want an 8” or 11” we can create a custom order for you.

With the new size, we also decided that we needed to raise our prices for the first time in four years. We know price increases are never easy, and we want to be completely open about why you've seen some changes on our menu. This isn't just about numbers—it's about staying true to our values and continuing to bring you the best possible products.

At Tootie Pie, every pie, every emPIEnada, and every Cutie Cake we bake carries our promise: to deliver the highest quality, handcrafted baked goods made with care—for our customers, our crew, and our community.

Quality First—Always

We believe food should be real. That's why we only use clean-label ingredients, which means no artificial flavors, no synthetic colors, no preservatives you can’t pronounce, and no shortcuts. Whether it's the farm-fresh eggs, premium butter, or the fruits we source, we choose ingredients grown in the USA that reflect our commitment to quality and your well-being. These ingredients cost more—but they’re worth it.

Handcrafted with Care

We aren't a factory—and we never will be. Every pie crust and filling is made from scratch, every emPIEnada is shaped by hand, and everything is baked by skilled bakers who take pride in their craft. That time, skill, and attention to detail simply can't be rushed or mass-produced—and it's what makes our bakery truly special.

Supporting Our Crew

Our bakery isn’t just about flour and sugar—it’s about people. To continue offering you exceptional service and products, we need to take care of the amazing team that makes it all happen. That means providing fair wages, benefits, and a safe work environment where our staff can thrive. We're proud to invest in our team, even as labor costs rise.

Caring for Our Customers

Raising prices isn’t a decision we take lightly, especially now. But cutting corners isn’t an option—not for us, and not for the quality you deserve. This small adjustment helps us keep our shelves full of the delicious, responsibly-made treats you've come to love.

We’re grateful for your understanding and continued support. Thank you for choosing to shop local, to support handcrafted baking, and to share in our passion for honest, quality food. We couldn’t do it without you.

Bake it a great day!

Brian, Jamie and your Tootie Pie Team