Tootie's "Original" Apple Pie is filled with fresh apples, mixed with the perfect blend of brown sugar and cinnamon, and then covered with a blanket of our secret crust. The result is almost 6 pounds of mouthwatering bliss. As many loyal customers have confirmed, you don't have to be an apple pie fan to find yourself hooked on Tootie's "Original" Apple Pie. Once you see it, smell it, and then taste it, you will know why it has won so many awards. Order one today and see what the fuss is all about!
Serves 8 - 10 (depending on how hungry you are!)
Showing reviews 1-10 of 73 | Next
Best pie ever.
Posted by Donna Evans on 17th Nov 2017
The only pie crust I’ll eat. Monstrous amount of apples and none of that fake gel in it!
Always a Winner
Posted by Lori Ehly on 17th Nov 2017
Quick and easy order and delivery. And it's always a crowd pleaser.
Posted by Connie on 22nd Aug 2017
I have been ordering pies for awhile for others. Just last week I ordered our 1st pie for my husband and I to enjoy....we got the apple pie and just loved it. I will order for us more often.
In the beginning ...
Posted by David on 28th Jul 2017
In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth ... and apples. Then Tootie Pie Company took over from there. The "Original" Apple Pie was created, and still is being handcrafted for you and me. Lots of apples and a special "secret" crust make this pie a magnificent order for yourself or a gift for someone you love. Go ahead, take a bite. Now another bite. Tastes so good you'll need to order another one.
The BEST... always!
Posted by Bevo on 27th May 2017
We've been buying Tootie Pies since the REAL Tootie Fagan was baking them in her shop in Medina, TX around 1999-2000. You can't bake or buy an apple pie anywhere that compares to Tootie's Original Apple Pie. We buy them for an occasional treat for ourselves and give them as "thank you" gifts to friends and family. People are shocked when they see the size of these pies and how wonderful the crust and apples taste. You won't go wrong ordering this pie. I only wish the price could be lowered a little so we could treat ourselves to them more often. Back in 2000, Tootie sold them in her shop in Medina for about $14.00 a pie, and I know this is 2017, but please consider not being quite so proud of your pie and bringing the price down...even a little bit.
Posted by Unknown on 5th May 2017
The apple pie was sent to me as a gift a year ago and I thought it was delicious. I ordered one recently for a dessert pot luck at our school. It was the first item gone! Not only is it great tasting, but impressive to look at as well. Several teachers remarked that it was the best apple pie they had ever eaten too.
Posted by Unknown on 19th Apr 2017
Easter celebration was complete with Tootie Apple Pie-five little grands and their parents enjoyed.
Best Apple Pie Ever
Posted by norma donaldson on 16th Apr 2017
Over the past 3 years, I have received and sent Tootie Apple pies. It is the Christmas favorite at our house. The kids and adults rave over the size and taste of the pie. It is delivered frozen, so it tastes fresh baked when served. The company excels in communicating delivery times and options. It is a pleasure to do business with them. If you are thinking the pies are an expensive gift, know that they are worth every penny.
Best apple pie ever!
Posted by Unknown on 25th Mar 2017
Six pounds of delicious apple pie. Tastes like homemade.
Will definitely order again!
Best Pie In Texas!
Posted by Terri Colunga on 2nd Mar 2017
I have ordered your pies a few times before for the holidays. My son is now in the Military and was so surprised and happy when I sent him the Apple Pie! Our family absolutely loves your pies!
Showing reviews 1-10 of 73 | Next