Some people are coconut pie fanatics. Leave it to Tootie to create a pie that makes all other coconut pies pale in comparison. Of course, it starts with our amazing crust, which we fill with sweet, creamy custard. Then, instead of meringue, it's blanketed with a scrumptious layer of toasted coconut giving it a rich, chewy texture. Some folks top it with whipped cream. Either way, if you love coconut pie, you’ve just found your soul mate.
Serves 8 - 10 (depending on how hungry you are!)
Posted by Jullie Huffman on 4th Jun 2016
I liked the pie but for us it was a little too sweet
Posted by Unknown on 6th Apr 2015
Flavor of the coconut pie was very good. Most felt the pie was a bit dry; needing more custard perhaps.
Best coconut pie!
Posted by Jason on 25th Dec 2014
Ordered this pie to take to a Christmas party. Looked so good when it arrived. Just had to taste it. Needless to say it didn't make it to the party?
Amazing coconut cream
Posted by Robert on 28th Apr 2014
I was worried when I ordered the pie on what shape it would arrive in, especially when I got home and noted it was sitting on my doorstep with the "This end up" facing towards the ground. No problems--it was packed very, very well and took no damage in shipping. It wasn't what I thought a traditional, cheap cream pie would be--it had a firm, rich texture and my boys ate it up!