Guess which pie is Tootie’s favorite – it’s Buttermilk! This pie is something special: it’s just the right balance of sweet custard and golden crust. One bite and you’ll see why it’s one of our most popular pies across the country.
Serves 8 - 10 (depending on how hungry you are!)
Posted by Cheryle Guillet on 14th Aug 2017
Wonderful flavor. Always fresh
Posted by Unknown on 3rd Aug 2017
I don't care much for sweets but this pie is EXCELLENT!
the most amazing buttermilk pie
Posted by firstname.lastname@example.org on 27th Dec 2016
When you want the real thing, the Tootie pie company does it right. It is exactly what you want a buttermilk pie should taste like.
Best ever !
Posted by Unknown on 3rd Jun 2016
Dare I say it's better than my Nana's!
Best pie EVER!
Posted by scott on 6th Jun 2015
Better than cheesecake. Just add some topping (or not) and always a hit.
My Favorite Pie
Posted by Michael F on 17th May 2015
Love the sweet custard taste of this pie. To me it is perfect.
Posted by Don on 29th Nov 2014
My favorite for Thanksgiving
Posted by Unknown on 26th Dec 2013
My family and friends are all smiles when this incredible pie is served at Christmas dinner.